Files
autocad-mcp-pro/benchmarks/correctness_suite.py
T
Umut CANandClaude Opus 5 b03a7615b1 release: v1.5.0 — discovery layer, honesty debt closed, Wave A
Tool count 131 -> 154; 474 -> 1242 collected tests.

The release exists for two measured reasons. A 149-tool catalog costs a client
~40,300 tokens before it has asked for anything, and a drafter searching the way
drafters think -- FILLET, BPOLY, QSELECT, WBLOCK -- scored df=0 against the stock
index, because those words were simply not in the data.

Discovery and batching
- DISCOVERY_MODE=search replaces the catalog with search_tools + call_tool,
  ranked over an AutoCAD command and synonym corpus (discovery/aliases.py) on
  top of fastmcp's BM25 index. Measured: 40,305 -> 356 tokens advertised.
- cad_batch runs a step list in one round trip; fields= projects result-heavy
  responses. The `core` profile is gone -- discovery replaced it.

Honesty debt (Tier 0)
- OCS/ECS: `extrusion` appeared nowhere in this codebase, so mirrored and
  rotated geometry reported coordinates that were quietly wrong. backends/ocs.py
  translates at the backend boundary; every tool coordinate is WCS on both
  engines, and a tilted plane refuses rather than answering with a number that
  looks fine.
- drawing_save_as(fmt="dwg") wrote DXF bytes to a .dwg path. drawing_audit never
  repaired. analysis_measure_area shoelaced points the caller typed in.
- ezdxf calls gained a per-call timeout, so one hung call can no longer wedge a
  server whose document lock is a single asyncio.Lock.

Architecture
- The 1854-line backend ABC is 19 contract modules; @capability(key, reason=)
  makes optional methods declarative and a gate fails on undeclared holes.
- 8 layout/viewport tools, CHSPACE, CAD_PROGID escape hatch.
- Wave A: selection filters, boundary tracing, hatch depth, annotation objects,
  measurement -- 13 tools of a planned 39. The REGION and 2D-boolean family was
  cut on evidence: add_region() yields zero ACIS bytes and the greiner_hormann
  substitute loses 28.2% of the area on a square with one semicircular edge.

Verified against a live AutoCAD 2026, which found four COM defects no amount of
reading would have caught -- AcadPViewport has no ViewCenter, and the line that
set it had been swallowed by a bare except since v1.4.

Benchmark v3 (15 tasks) and what it caught
- v2 scored this server 10/10, which carried no information: every task in it
  exercised something the server was built around. Five tasks were added because
  they can fail, and three did while being written -- a hatch could not be
  measured though the refusal listed HATCH as measurable, the boundary tools and
  the measure tool disagreed about the same shape (139.2177 vs 139.2699), and a
  circle stored as two bulged vertices measured 0.0.
- Competitor reports are NOT re-scored. They are pinned v1.4 runs against v2 and
  were never asked these five questions; the chart shows those rows `not run`.
- Correctness A/B: 21/24 -> 24/24, zero regressions.

Performance, stated plainly
The published v1.4 perf report was recorded on CPython 3.14 and the new one on
3.11.15, so the apparent 2-6x speedup is the interpreter, not this release.
Re-measured on one interpreter, v1.5.0 is 28% slower creating entities and 22%
slower on the 10k roundtrip. Fully attributed: EZDXF_CALL_TIMEOUT=0 restores
v1.4.0's exact numbers. That is the deadlock fix being paid for, the knob is
documented, and winning it back is on the 1.6 roadmap.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-06 09:45:20 +03:00

320 lines
12 KiB
Python

"""Version-agnostic correctness checks for the AutoCAD MCP ezdxf backend.
Driven by ``compare_versions.py`` (the A/B runner). Run ONE check in isolation:
python benchmarks/correctness_suite.py <check_name>
python benchmarks/correctness_suite.py --list
Prints 'PASS' or 'FAIL' on the last line; a crash (e.g. SIGSEGV) or an
unsupported method => non-zero exit, which the runner counts as a miss.
The same file is executed against both the baseline worktree and the current
checkout (PYTHONPATH + cwd point at each repo), so a check that exercises a
method the old version lacks simply raises AttributeError -> miss.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import asyncio
import math
import os
import sys
import tempfile
async def _b():
from backends.ezdxf_backend import EzdxfBackend
be = EzdxfBackend()
await be.connect()
await be.drawing_new()
return be
# ── Core capability (expected to pass on BOTH versions — sanity / not rigged) ──
async def core_line_length():
b = await _b()
ln = await b.entity_create_line(0, 0, 3, 4)
info = await b.entity_get(ln.handle)
return abs(float(info.properties["length"]) - 5.0) < 1e-6
async def core_circle_radius():
b = await _b()
c = await b.entity_create_circle(0, 0, 10)
info = await b.entity_get(c.handle)
return abs(float(info.properties["radius"]) - 10.0) < 1e-6
async def core_layer_create():
b = await _b()
await b.layer_create("BENCH", color=1)
names = {lyr.name for lyr in await b.layer_list()}
return "BENCH" in names
async def core_polyline_closed():
b = await _b()
p = await b.entity_create_polyline([[0, 0], [10, 0], [10, 10]], closed=True)
info = await b.entity_get(p.handle)
return bool(info.properties.get("closed"))
async def core_linear_dim():
b = await _b()
d = await b.dimension_linear(0, 0, 100, 0, 50, 20)
info = await b.entity_get(d.handle)
return "DIM" in info.type.upper()
async def core_save_dxf_roundtrip():
b = await _b()
await b.entity_create_line(0, 0, 10, 10)
path = os.path.join(tempfile.mkdtemp(), "rt.dxf")
await b.drawing_save_as(path, "dxf")
import ezdxf
ezdxf.readfile(path) # raises if not a valid DXF
return os.path.getsize(path) > 0
# ── Dimensions (I16) ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
async def dim_aligned_no_error():
b = await _b()
d = await b.dimension_aligned(0, 0, 50, 50, 30, 70)
return d is not None
async def dim_angular_no_error():
b = await _b()
d = await b.dimension_angular(0, 0, 100, 0, 0, 100, 60, 60)
return d is not None
# ── Polar array full circle (R9) ──────────────────────────────────────────────
async def array_polar_360_distinct():
b = await _b()
c = await b.entity_create_circle(10, 0, 1)
res = await b.entity_array_polar(c.handle, 4, 360.0, 0, 0)
# 3 copies + original = 4 distinct centers, none coincident with the original.
centers = {(10.0, 0.0)}
for e in res:
info = await b.entity_get(e.handle if hasattr(e, "handle") else e)
cx, cy = info.properties["center"]
centers.add((round(cx, 3), round(cy, 3)))
return len(centers) == 4
# ── Deterministic geometry (I9) ────────────────────────────────────────────────
async def point_intersection_line_line():
b = await _b()
l1 = await b.entity_create_line(0, 0, 10, 0)
l2 = await b.entity_create_line(5, -5, 5, 5)
pt = await b.point_intersection(l1.handle, l2.handle)
return abs(pt[0] - 5.0) < 1e-6 and abs(pt[1] - 0.0) < 1e-6
async def point_tangent_external():
b = await _b()
c = await b.entity_create_circle(0, 0, 3)
tx, ty = await b.point_tangent(c.handle, 5, 0, ref_y=10)
# tangency: (T-F).(T-C) == 0 and |T-C| == r
fx, fy = 5.0, 0.0
dot = (tx - fx) * (tx - 0) + (ty - fy) * (ty - 0)
return abs(dot) < 1e-4 and abs(math.hypot(tx, ty) - 3.0) < 1e-4
# ── Selection / property parity (N3, N5) ───────────────────────────────────────
async def arc_has_length():
b = await _b()
a = await b.entity_create_arc(0, 0, 10, 0, 90)
info = await b.entity_get(a.handle)
return abs(float(info.properties["length"]) - (10 * math.pi / 2)) < 1e-3
async def arc_select_by_length():
b = await _b()
await b.entity_create_arc(0, 0, 10, 0, 90) # length ~15.7
sel = await b.entity_select_smart({"type": "ARC", "length_range": [15, 16]})
return len(sel) == 1
async def ezdxf_bounding_box():
b = await _b()
ln = await b.entity_create_line(0, 0, 30, 40)
info = await b.entity_get(ln.handle)
bb = info.properties.get("bounding_box")
return isinstance(bb, dict) and set(bb) == {"min", "max"}
async def mtext_rotation_roundtrip():
b = await _b()
mt = await b.entity_create_mtext("r", 0, 0, width=50, height=2.5, rotation=30.0)
info = await b.entity_get(mt.handle)
return abs(float(info.properties.get("rotation", 0.0)) - 30.0) < 1e-6
# ── Rendering (screenshot Agg / SIGSEGV) ───────────────────────────────────────
async def screenshot_png():
b = await _b()
await b.entity_create_line(0, 0, 100, 100)
png = await b.view_screenshot()
return png is not None and png[:4] == b"\x89PNG"
# ── Quality gate / critique (R4, N4) ───────────────────────────────────────────
async def dim_overlap_critique_fires():
b = await _b()
await b.drawing_apply_iso_layers("mech")
await b.dimension_linear(0, 0, 100, 0, 50, 20, layer="DIM")
await b.dimension_linear(0, 0, 100, 0, 50, 20, layer="DIM")
issues = await b.drawing_critique(focus=["dim_overlap"])
return len(issues) >= 1
async def iso13567_dim_layer():
b = await _b()
await b.drawing_apply_iso_layers("iso13567")
ln = await b.entity_create_line(0, 0, 80, 0, layer="M-GEOMET-E-N")
dims = await b.dimension_auto([ln.handle], style="chain")
return dims[0].layer == "M-DIMEN-T-N"
async def construction_left_iso_caught():
b = await _b()
await b.drawing_apply_iso_layers("iso13567")
await b.construction_xline(0, 0, 90)
issues = await b.drawing_critique(focus=["construction_left"])
return len(issues) == 1
# ── Engineering (gear) ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
async def gear_no_self_overlap():
from engineering.gear import generate_full_gear_outline
pts = generate_full_gear_outline(2, 50, 20.0) # z=50 -> root_r >= base_r
root_r = (2 * 50 / 2.0) - 1.25 * 2
return min(math.hypot(x, y) for x, y in pts) >= root_r - 1e-6
# ── Linetype on demand (R24) ───────────────────────────────────────────────────
async def center_linetype_applied():
b = await _b()
ln = await b.entity_create_line(0, 0, 50, 0, linetype="CENTER")
info = await b.entity_get(ln.handle)
return info.linetype.upper() == "CENTER"
# ── Measurement (v1.5.0) ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────
#
# These three are NEW capability, not repaired regressions: v1.4.0 has no
# `entity_measure` and no boundary tracing, so it misses them by not having the
# method rather than by getting it wrong. They are here because all three broke
# during v1.5.0 development and nothing outside their own unit tests would have
# noticed.
async def hatch_area_subtracts_its_island():
"""A section view is mostly holes; counting them is a 33% error here."""
b = await _b()
h = await b.entity_create_hatch("ANSI31", [[0, 0], [20, 0], [20, 20], [0, 20]])
await b.hatch_add_boundary(
h.handle,
[
{"type": "line", "start": [5, 5], "end": [15, 5]},
{"type": "line", "start": [15, 5], "end": [15, 15]},
{"type": "line", "start": [15, 15], "end": [5, 15]},
{"type": "line", "start": [5, 15], "end": [5, 5]},
],
)
return abs((await b.entity_measure(h.handle))["area"] - 300.0) < 1e-6
async def boundary_area_agrees_with_measure():
"""Two tools, one shape, one number."""
b = await _b()
await b.entity_create_line(0, 0, 10, 0)
await b.entity_create_line(10, 0, 10, 10)
await b.entity_create_line(0, 10, 0, 0)
await b.entity_create_arc(5, 10, 5, 0, 180)
loop = await b.boundary_trace(5.0, 5.0)
measured = await b.entity_measure(loop["handle"])
true_area = 100.0 + math.pi * 25.0 / 2.0
return abs(loop["area"] - measured["area"]) < 1e-9 and abs(measured["area"] - true_area) < 1e-5
async def two_vertex_circle_has_area():
"""DXF's most compact circle. The shoelace over its two points is 0."""
from engineering.measure import polygon_area_perimeter
area, _ = polygon_area_perimeter([(-10.0, 0.0, 1.0), (10.0, 0.0, 1.0)], closed=True)
return abs(area - math.pi * 100.0) < 1e-9
CHECKS = {
"core_line_length": (core_line_length, "Core"),
"core_circle_radius": (core_circle_radius, "Core"),
"core_layer_create": (core_layer_create, "Core"),
"core_polyline_closed": (core_polyline_closed, "Core"),
"core_linear_dim": (core_linear_dim, "Core"),
"core_save_dxf_roundtrip": (core_save_dxf_roundtrip, "Core"),
"dim_aligned_no_error": (dim_aligned_no_error, "Dimensions"),
"dim_angular_no_error": (dim_angular_no_error, "Dimensions"),
"array_polar_360_distinct": (array_polar_360_distinct, "Modify"),
"point_intersection_line_line": (point_intersection_line_line, "Geometry"),
"point_tangent_external": (point_tangent_external, "Geometry"),
"arc_has_length": (arc_has_length, "Query"),
"arc_select_by_length": (arc_select_by_length, "Query"),
"ezdxf_bounding_box": (ezdxf_bounding_box, "Query"),
"mtext_rotation_roundtrip": (mtext_rotation_roundtrip, "Entities"),
"screenshot_png": (screenshot_png, "Render"),
"dim_overlap_critique_fires": (dim_overlap_critique_fires, "Quality gate"),
"iso13567_dim_layer": (iso13567_dim_layer, "Quality gate"),
"construction_left_iso_caught": (construction_left_iso_caught, "Quality gate"),
"gear_no_self_overlap": (gear_no_self_overlap, "Engineering"),
"center_linetype_applied": (center_linetype_applied, "Entities"),
"hatch_area_subtracts_its_island": (hatch_area_subtracts_its_island, "Measurement"),
"boundary_area_agrees_with_measure": (boundary_area_agrees_with_measure, "Measurement"),
"two_vertex_circle_has_area": (two_vertex_circle_has_area, "Measurement"),
}
def main():
if len(sys.argv) == 1 or sys.argv[1] in {"-h", "--help"}:
print("usage: correctness_suite.py <check_name> | --list")
print("Run one deterministic correctness check, or list available checks.")
return
if len(sys.argv) == 2 and sys.argv[1] == "--list":
for k, (_fn, cat) in CHECKS.items():
print(f"{k}\t{cat}")
return
name = sys.argv[1]
if name not in CHECKS:
print(f"Unknown check: {name}", file=sys.stderr)
raise SystemExit(2)
fn, _cat = CHECKS[name]
ok = asyncio.run(fn())
print("PASS" if ok else "FAIL")
if __name__ == "__main__":
main()