Files
autocad-mcp-pro/engineering/critique.py
T
Umutcan Edizsalan 702af0d6e1 fix: P0 — COM premium crash, lineweight truncation, ISO critique no-op
Three production-blocking defects + two legal/infra gaps from the recon pass.

R1 (CRITICAL): the 8 premium meta-tools (drawing_plan, drawing_critique,
point_from_snap, construction_xline, construction_clear, drawing_apply_iso_layers,
dimension_auto, entity_select_smart) raised NotImplementedError on the COM
backend — i.e. the entire "non-negotiable" premium workflow crashed on the
DEFAULT Windows backend. Lifted all eight to AutoCADBackend as concrete,
backend-agnostic implementations built on the shared abstract primitives +
the identical EntityInfo.properties contract, so both backends inherit them.
The only backend-specific piece left is the new `_create_xline` primitive
(XLINE has no cross-backend entity_create_* equivalent). Removes ~285 lines of
ezdxf-only duplication; the existing meta-tool test suite now covers shared code.

R2 (CRITICAL): layer_create/layer_modify/entity_set_properties used
int(lineweight), truncating every millimetre lineweight (0.50, 0.25, 0.18, 0.13)
to 0 — silently wiping the whole ISO 128 discipline, because engineering/layers.py
passes mm-floats while the MCP boundary passes hundredths-ints. Added
normalize_lineweight() to reconcile both conventions to ezdxf/COM hundredths and
wired it into all six call sites.

R3 (HIGH): _check_iso128 was a permanent no-op (everything was 0 from R2, so the
`lw <= 0: continue` guard skipped all layers). Fixed by R2; additionally exclude
CONSTRUCTION-class layers (intentionally sub-ISO 0.05mm scratch weight) to avoid
a new false positive, and corrected the misleading "normalises to mm" comment.

Also: add MIT LICENSE (referenced by CLAUDE.md but missing — legal gap) and
restore .github/workflows/ci.yml (lint kept non-blocking until the repo-wide
ruff cleanup; the test job is the real gate).

Verified: 182 passed / 2 xfailed; functional check confirms lineweights now
store as hundredths (GEOMETRY=50) and the ISO critique correctly flags a 0.40mm
layer while passing a clean ISO drawing.
2026-06-18 10:02:09 +03:00

252 lines
8.9 KiB
Python

"""Premium-quality critique checks for finished drawings.
Each focus runs an independent check; new focuses must be added to the
`CritiqueFocus` Literal in plan_spec.py *and* registered here. Closed enum
keeps drawing_critique scope from drifting.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import math
from typing import TYPE_CHECKING
from .layers import ENGINEERING_LAYERS
from .plan_spec import (
ALL_CRITIQUE_FOCUSES,
ISO_128_LINEWEIGHTS_MM,
CritiqueFocus,
Issue,
)
if TYPE_CHECKING:
from backends.base import AutoCADBackend
# Layer-name → expected ACI color, derived from ENGINEERING_LAYERS.
_EXPECTED_LAYER_COLOR: dict[str, int] = {
name: color for name, color, _lt, _lw, _desc in ENGINEERING_LAYERS
}
# Dimension entity types that should sit on the DIM layer.
_DIM_TYPES = {
"DIMENSION", "DIMLINEAR", "DIMALIGNED", "DIMANGULAR",
"DIMRADIUS", "DIMDIAMETER", "DIMORDINATE",
}
async def _check_iso128(backend: "AutoCADBackend") -> list[Issue]:
"""Layer lineweights must be in ISO_128_LINEWEIGHTS_MM (or -3=ByLayer
sentinel meaning 'inherit')."""
issues: list[Issue] = []
try:
layers = await backend.layer_list()
except Exception as exc:
return [Issue("warning", "iso128", f"layer_list failed: {exc}")]
allowed = set(ISO_128_LINEWEIGHTS_MM)
for lyr in layers:
# CONSTRUCTION-class layers are intentionally sub-ISO (0.05mm scratch
# weight) and must be cleared before finalize — never an ISO violation.
if "CONST" in lyr.name.upper():
continue
lw = float(lyr.lineweight)
# AutoCAD sentinels: -1 (Default), -2 (ByBlock), -3 (ByLayer);
# 0.0 = ezdxf's "use default" — not an ISO 128 violation.
if lw <= 0:
continue
# Layer lineweights come through as ezdxf/COM hundredths-of-a-mm
# (e.g. 25 == 0.25mm) — they are NOT pre-normalised to mm, so accept
# either the raw mm value or hundredths/100.
if lw not in allowed and (lw / 100.0) not in allowed:
issues.append(Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="iso128",
message=(
f"Layer '{lyr.name}' lineweight {lw} mm is not in the "
f"ISO 128 set {sorted(allowed)}."
),
detail={"layer": lyr.name, "lineweight": lw},
))
return issues
async def _check_layer_color(backend: "AutoCADBackend") -> list[Issue]:
"""Engineering-standard layers must keep their canonical ACI color."""
issues: list[Issue] = []
try:
layers = await backend.layer_list()
except Exception:
return []
for lyr in layers:
expected = _EXPECTED_LAYER_COLOR.get(lyr.name)
if expected is None:
continue # unknown layer — caller's responsibility
if int(lyr.color) != int(expected):
issues.append(Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="layer_color",
message=(
f"Layer '{lyr.name}' has color {lyr.color}; "
f"engineering standard expects {expected}."
),
detail={"layer": lyr.name, "got": int(lyr.color), "expected": expected},
))
return issues
async def _check_construction_left(backend: "AutoCADBackend") -> list[Issue]:
"""CONSTRUCTION layer must be empty before drawing_finalize."""
try:
ents = await backend.entity_list(layer_filter="CONSTRUCTION", limit=5000)
except Exception:
return []
if not ents:
return []
return [Issue(
severity="error",
focus="construction_left",
message=(
f"{len(ents)} entity/entities still on CONSTRUCTION layer. "
"Call construction_clear() before drawing_finalize."
),
handles=[e.handle for e in ents[:50]],
detail={"count": len(ents)},
)]
async def _check_untrimmed_corner(backend: "AutoCADBackend") -> list[Issue]:
"""Two LINE endpoints within `tol` but not exactly equal usually means a
corner where one line overshoots — TRIM/EXTEND/FILLET was forgotten."""
tol = 0.5 # mm — generous; tighten via PlanSpec.notes later
try:
lines = await backend.entity_list(type_filter="LINE", limit=5000)
except Exception:
return []
endpoints: list[tuple[str, tuple[float, float]]] = []
for ln in lines:
s = ln.properties.get("start")
e = ln.properties.get("end")
if s and e:
endpoints.append((ln.handle, (float(s[0]), float(s[1]))))
endpoints.append((ln.handle, (float(e[0]), float(e[1]))))
issues: list[Issue] = []
n = len(endpoints)
seen: set[frozenset[str]] = set()
for i in range(n):
h1, p1 = endpoints[i]
for j in range(i + 1, n):
h2, p2 = endpoints[j]
if h1 == h2:
continue
d = math.hypot(p1[0] - p2[0], p1[1] - p2[1])
if 1e-9 < d <= tol:
key = frozenset((h1, h2))
if key in seen:
continue
seen.add(key)
issues.append(Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="untrimmed_corner",
message=(
f"Lines {h1} and {h2} have endpoints {d:.3f} mm apart — "
"likely an untrimmed corner (use entity_trim or entity_fillet)."
),
handles=[h1, h2],
detail={"gap_mm": d, "p1": list(p1), "p2": list(p2)},
))
return issues
async def _check_duplicate_entities(backend: "AutoCADBackend") -> list[Issue]:
"""Two LINEs with identical endpoints (in either direction) are duplicates."""
try:
lines = await backend.entity_list(type_filter="LINE", limit=5000)
except Exception:
return []
seen: dict[tuple, str] = {}
issues: list[Issue] = []
for ln in lines:
s = ln.properties.get("start")
e = ln.properties.get("end")
if not (s and e):
continue
k1 = (round(s[0], 4), round(s[1], 4), round(e[0], 4), round(e[1], 4))
k2 = (k1[2], k1[3], k1[0], k1[1])
for key in (k1, k2):
if key in seen:
issues.append(Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="duplicate_entities",
message=f"Lines {seen[key]} and {ln.handle} are duplicates.",
handles=[seen[key], ln.handle],
))
break
else:
seen[k1] = ln.handle
return issues
async def _check_dim_overlap(backend: "AutoCADBackend") -> list[Issue]:
"""Two dimensions whose insertion points are within `tol` likely overlap."""
tol = 5.0 # mm
try:
ents = await backend.entity_list(layer_filter="DIM", limit=5000)
except Exception:
return []
dim_points: list[tuple[str, tuple[float, float]]] = []
for e in ents:
if e.type not in _DIM_TYPES and "DIM" not in e.type:
continue
ip = (e.properties.get("text_position")
or e.properties.get("defpoint")
or e.properties.get("insertion_point"))
if ip and len(ip) >= 2:
dim_points.append((e.handle, (float(ip[0]), float(ip[1]))))
issues: list[Issue] = []
seen: set[frozenset[str]] = set()
for i, (h1, p1) in enumerate(dim_points):
for j in range(i + 1, len(dim_points)):
h2, p2 = dim_points[j]
d = math.hypot(p1[0] - p2[0], p1[1] - p2[1])
if d <= tol:
key = frozenset((h1, h2))
if key in seen:
continue
seen.add(key)
issues.append(Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="dim_overlap",
message=f"Dimensions {h1} and {h2} are {d:.2f} mm apart — likely overlapping.",
handles=[h1, h2],
))
return issues
_FOCUS_DISPATCH = {
"iso128": _check_iso128,
"layer_color": _check_layer_color,
"dim_overlap": _check_dim_overlap,
"untrimmed_corner": _check_untrimmed_corner,
"duplicate_entities": _check_duplicate_entities,
"construction_left": _check_construction_left,
}
async def run_critique(
backend: "AutoCADBackend",
focus: list[CritiqueFocus] | None = None,
) -> list[Issue]:
"""Dispatch each requested focus check and return aggregated issues."""
foci = list(focus) if focus is not None else list(ALL_CRITIQUE_FOCUSES)
issues: list[Issue] = []
for f in foci:
check = _FOCUS_DISPATCH.get(f)
if check is None:
issues.append(Issue(
severity="warning",
focus=f, # type: ignore[arg-type]
message=f"Unknown critique focus '{f}' (closed enum).",
))
continue
issues.extend(await check(backend))
return issues