Files
autocad-mcp-pro/engineering/critique.py
T
Umut CANandClaude Opus 5 ca1c79fd01
Release / test (full, windows-latest, 3.11) (push) Canceled after 0s
Release / test (pdf, ubuntu-latest, 3.11) (push) Canceled after 0s
Release / test (pdf, ubuntu-latest, 3.12) (push) Canceled after 0s
Release / build (push) Canceled after 0s
Release / publish-pypi (push) Canceled after 0s
Release / github-release (push) Canceled after 0s
fix: seven defects an adversarial audit found, and the gates that missed them
Every one of these was reported ok/clean to the caller while being wrong.

Silently wrong numbers
- selection_filter(min_area) read `entity.dxf.get("area", 0.0)` for SOLID,
  TRACE and HATCH, none of which carry that attribute, so every hatch
  measured 0.0. A 1600 mm^2 hatch was excluded by min_area=1.0 while
  `filtered_by` asserted the filter had run, and COM (which reads ActiveX
  .Area) returned a different selection for the same call. It now answers
  from the measurement `entity_measure` uses, so the two cannot disagree.
- Every headless dimension rendered through ezdxf's bare `Standard` style:
  1.0 mm text with a comma decimal marker, against ISO 3098's 2.5 mm minimum
  and ISO 129's point -- while the document header itself said $DIMTXT 2.5.
  `ezdxf.new(setup=True)` is not the fix; measured, it renders a 100 mm
  dimension as "10000". The attributes are now stored explicitly.
- Saving writes `dimrnd = 0.0` onto the Standard style, and ezdxf applies
  `xround(value, dimrnd)` whenever the attribute is present at all --
  `xround(33.333, 0.0)` is 33. So on any reopened file, including one this
  server saved, every dimension was rounded to a whole unit before DIMDEC
  formatted it: a 12.75 mm feature dimensioned 13. AutoCAD means DIMRND 0 as
  *no* rounding; the sentinel is now discarded at every load site, and a real
  0.5 mm rounding is left alone.
- The DIM* header fold gave out-of-range values teeth they did not have when
  they died in the header: dim_decimals=-1 returned ok and then killed the
  next dimension with `ValueError: Format specifier missing precision` from
  inside ezdxf, and 40 printed forty digits of float noise onto the sheet.
  Ranges are now AutoCAD's own (DIMDEC 0-8, DIMZIN 0-15, lengths positive).

Security
- security.py recorded the policy as "sanitize_command and sanitize_lisp each
  have exactly ONE caller ... the policy is scoped to the CHANNEL". The
  premise was false. `_ensure_linetype_loaded` and `ComBackend.linetype_load`
  build `_-LINETYPE _LOAD {name} {file}` and hand it to SendCommand, which
  treats a newline and ';' as segment separators -- so a `linetype=` argument
  carrying either injected further AutoCAD commands, and the 36-verb denylist
  never saw that channel. Guarded with the DXF symbol-name rule (the
  injection characters fall out of it rather than being enumerated) plus
  validate_path for the file argument, which was also the one path-taking
  tool reaching the filesystem unchecked. The policy comment is corrected.

Gates that could not see
- drawing_critique returned zero issues on a quarantined document: all seven
  checks wrapped their backend call in a bare `except Exception`. CLAUDE.md
  rule 7 makes that call the gate an agent is told to trust. Only the
  quarantine now escapes; an ordinary broken check still degrades.
  `_check_dimension_legibility` also read `_doc` directly from the event loop
  thread, missing the gate and performing exactly the unsynchronised access
  the quarantine exists to prevent. `construction_clear` answered
  "deleted: 0" -- there was nothing to clear -- for the same reason.
- The iso128 focus checked layer lineweights only, so a sheet lettered at
  1.0 mm critiqued clean. It now reads the effective dimension height and
  separator, header-then-style, in the order the renderer resolves.
- check_doc_numbers.py derived five values it never checked, and those were
  the ones that had drifted. The collected-test count (README said 1274, the
  tree had 1369) and the A/B pass-rate and Fixed columns are now gated.
- benchmarks/README.md's v1.4.0 table was impossible on its face -- 21
  passing plus 5 fixed is 26, not 24 -- and contradicted the report it
  linked, because `ab-v1.4.0-vs-v1.5.0.json` was regenerated from a tree that
  already carried the dimension fixes and so never measured the v1.5.0 tag.
  Replaced with a real run: ab-v1.4.0-vs-v1.5.1.json, 21/26 -> 26/26.

Release gate
- release.yml ran one ubuntu/3.11 lane, so a Windows-only defect could reach
  PyPI with no Windows job having executed. That is not hypothetical: v1.5.0
  shipped `except pywintypes.com_error` raising NameError wherever pywin32 is
  absent. It now runs the same three lanes as ci.yml, Windows included.

1368 passed, 1 xfailed. ruff clean. Tool inventory and all 16 gated document
numbers match the tree.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-06 23:07:50 +03:00

432 lines
16 KiB
Python

"""Premium-quality critique checks for finished drawings.
Each focus runs an independent check; new focuses must be added to the
`CritiqueFocus` Literal in plan_spec.py *and* registered here. Closed enum
keeps drawing_critique scope from drifting.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import math
from typing import TYPE_CHECKING
from backends.quarantine import DocumentQuarantineError, quarantine_refusal
from .layers import ENGINEERING_LAYERS
from .plan_spec import (
ALL_CRITIQUE_FOCUSES,
ISO_128_LINEWEIGHTS_MM,
CritiqueFocus,
Issue,
)
if TYPE_CHECKING:
from backends.base import AutoCADBackend
# Layer-name → expected ACI color, derived from ENGINEERING_LAYERS.
_EXPECTED_LAYER_COLOR: dict[str, int] = {
name: color for name, color, _lt, _lw, _desc in ENGINEERING_LAYERS
}
# Dimension entity types that should sit on the DIM layer.
_DIM_TYPES = {
"DIMENSION",
"DIMLINEAR",
"DIMALIGNED",
"DIMANGULAR",
"DIMRADIUS",
"DIMDIAMETER",
"DIMORDINATE",
}
async def _check_iso128(backend: AutoCADBackend) -> list[Issue]:
"""Layer lineweights must be in ISO_128_LINEWEIGHTS_MM (or -3=ByLayer
sentinel meaning 'inherit')."""
issues: list[Issue] = []
try:
layers = await backend.layer_list()
except DocumentQuarantineError:
raise
except Exception as exc:
return [Issue("warning", "iso128", f"layer_list failed: {exc}")]
allowed = set(ISO_128_LINEWEIGHTS_MM)
for lyr in layers:
# CONSTRUCTION-class layers are intentionally sub-ISO (0.05mm scratch
# weight) and must be cleared before finalize — never an ISO violation.
if "CONST" in lyr.name.upper():
continue
lw = float(lyr.lineweight)
# AutoCAD sentinels: -1 (Default), -2 (ByBlock), -3 (ByLayer);
# 0.0 = ezdxf's "use default" — not an ISO 128 violation.
if lw <= 0:
continue
# Layer lineweights come through as ezdxf/COM hundredths-of-a-mm
# (e.g. 25 == 0.25mm) — they are NOT pre-normalised to mm, so accept
# either the raw mm value or hundredths/100.
if lw not in allowed and (lw / 100.0) not in allowed:
issues.append(
Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="iso128",
message=(
f"Layer '{lyr.name}' lineweight {lw} mm is not in the "
f"ISO 128 set {sorted(allowed)}."
),
detail={"layer": lyr.name, "lineweight": lw},
)
)
issues.extend(_check_dimension_legibility(backend))
return issues
#: ISO 3098 minimum lettering height for technical drawings, in mm.
ISO_3098_MIN_TEXT_MM = 2.5
def _check_dimension_legibility(backend: AutoCADBackend) -> list[Issue]:
"""Dimension text must be readable and use an ISO 129 decimal marker.
This lane was blind: `iso128` checked layer lineweights only, so a sheet
whose dimensions rendered at ezdxf's bare 1.0 mm with a comma separator
critiqued clean — and "zero issues" is the claim that the drawing is
conformant. Reading the settings rather than the rendered block keeps it
cheap and catches the case before a dimension is even drawn.
It reads the *effective* value — header first, then the stored dimstyle
attribute, then ezdxf's renderer fallback — because that is the order the
renderer resolves in since the DIM* header variables started reaching it.
Grading the dimstyle alone made this check wrong in both directions: it
would report a 1.0 mm defect on a sheet the header letters at 2.5, and clear
a sheet the header letters at 1.0 because the style still said 2.5.
Headless only by construction: a live AutoCAD document carries the
operator's own template, and second-guessing it from here would report
their house standard as a defect.
"""
doc = getattr(backend, "_doc", None)
if doc is None: # the live backend has no ezdxf document to read
return []
# This is the one check that reads `_doc` directly instead of going through
# `_async`, so it also misses `_async`'s quarantine gate — and it runs on
# the event loop thread, which is exactly the unsynchronised access to a
# document an abandoned worker may still be writing that the quarantine
# exists to prevent. Refuse here rather than read.
record = getattr(backend, "_quarantine", None)
if record is not None:
reap = getattr(backend, "_reap_quarantine", None)
if reap is not None:
reap()
record = getattr(backend, "_quarantine", None)
if record is not None:
raise quarantine_refusal(record)
from backends.ezdxf_backend import effective_dimvar
try:
height = float(effective_dimvar(doc, "dimtxt"))
separator = int(effective_dimvar(doc, "dimdsep"))
except DocumentQuarantineError:
raise
except Exception:
return []
issues: list[Issue] = []
if height < ISO_3098_MIN_TEXT_MM:
issues.append(
Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="iso128",
message=(
f"Dimension text is {height:g} mm; ISO 3098 sets the minimum "
f"lettering height at {ISO_3098_MIN_TEXT_MM} mm."
),
detail={"dimtxt": height, "minimum": ISO_3098_MIN_TEXT_MM},
)
)
# DIMDSEP 0 is not "unset" — ezdxf's `get_decimal_separator` renders it as a
# comma — so it is the violation, not an excuse to skip the check.
marker = "," if separator == 0 else chr(separator)
if marker != ".":
issues.append(
Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="iso128",
message=(f"Dimension decimal marker is {marker!r}; ISO 129 uses a point."),
detail={"dimdsep": separator},
)
)
return issues
async def _check_layer_color(backend: AutoCADBackend) -> list[Issue]:
"""Engineering-standard layers must keep their canonical ACI color."""
issues: list[Issue] = []
try:
layers = await backend.layer_list()
except DocumentQuarantineError:
raise
except Exception:
return []
for lyr in layers:
expected = _EXPECTED_LAYER_COLOR.get(lyr.name)
if expected is None:
continue # unknown layer — caller's responsibility
if int(lyr.color) != int(expected):
issues.append(
Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="layer_color",
message=(
f"Layer '{lyr.name}' has color {lyr.color}; "
f"engineering standard expects {expected}."
),
detail={"layer": lyr.name, "got": int(lyr.color), "expected": expected},
)
)
return issues
async def _check_construction_left(backend: AutoCADBackend) -> list[Issue]:
"""No construction/scratch geometry may remain before drawing_finalize.
Matches any layer whose name contains 'CONST' (CONSTRUCTION, M-CONST-E-N, …)
so the check is independent of the active layer set — a leftover iso13567
scaffold on M-CONST-E-N is caught just like a mech one on CONSTRUCTION.
"""
try:
ents = await backend.entity_list(limit=5000)
except DocumentQuarantineError:
raise
except Exception:
return []
leftover = [e for e in ents if "CONST" in (e.layer or "").upper()]
if not leftover:
return []
return [
Issue(
severity="error",
focus="construction_left",
message=(
f"{len(leftover)} entity/entities still on a construction layer. "
"Call construction_clear() before drawing_finalize."
),
handles=[e.handle for e in leftover[:50]],
detail={
"count": len(leftover),
"layers": sorted({e.layer for e in leftover if e.layer}),
},
)
]
async def _check_untrimmed_corner(backend: AutoCADBackend) -> list[Issue]:
"""Two LINE endpoints within `tol` but not exactly equal usually means a
corner where one line overshoots — TRIM/EXTEND/FILLET was forgotten."""
tol = 0.5 # mm — generous; tighten via PlanSpec.notes later
try:
lines = await backend.entity_list(type_filter="LINE", limit=5000)
except DocumentQuarantineError:
raise
except Exception:
return []
endpoints: list[tuple[str, tuple[float, float]]] = []
for ln in lines:
s = ln.properties.get("start")
e = ln.properties.get("end")
if s and e:
endpoints.append((ln.handle, (float(s[0]), float(s[1]))))
endpoints.append((ln.handle, (float(e[0]), float(e[1]))))
issues: list[Issue] = []
n = len(endpoints)
seen: set[frozenset[str]] = set()
for i in range(n):
h1, p1 = endpoints[i]
for j in range(i + 1, n):
h2, p2 = endpoints[j]
if h1 == h2:
continue
d = math.hypot(p1[0] - p2[0], p1[1] - p2[1])
if 1e-9 < d <= tol:
key = frozenset((h1, h2))
if key in seen:
continue
seen.add(key)
issues.append(
Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="untrimmed_corner",
message=(
f"Lines {h1} and {h2} have endpoints {d:.3f} mm apart — "
"likely an untrimmed corner (use entity_trim or entity_fillet)."
),
handles=[h1, h2],
detail={"gap_mm": d, "p1": list(p1), "p2": list(p2)},
)
)
return issues
async def _check_duplicate_entities(backend: AutoCADBackend) -> list[Issue]:
"""Two LINEs with identical endpoints (in either direction) are duplicates."""
try:
lines = await backend.entity_list(type_filter="LINE", limit=5000)
except DocumentQuarantineError:
raise
except Exception:
return []
seen: dict[tuple, str] = {}
issues: list[Issue] = []
for ln in lines:
s = ln.properties.get("start")
e = ln.properties.get("end")
if not (s and e):
continue
k1 = (round(s[0], 4), round(s[1], 4), round(e[0], 4), round(e[1], 4))
k2 = (k1[2], k1[3], k1[0], k1[1])
for key in (k1, k2):
if key in seen:
issues.append(
Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="duplicate_entities",
message=f"Lines {seen[key]} and {ln.handle} are duplicates.",
handles=[seen[key], ln.handle],
)
)
break
else:
seen[k1] = ln.handle
return issues
def _dim_ref_point(e) -> tuple[float, float] | None:
"""Best-effort reference point for a dimension entity, tolerant of the
per-backend property shape: explicit text/def points first, then the
bounding-box centre (COM seeds `bounding_box` for every entity)."""
for key in ("text_position", "defpoint", "insertion_point", "insertion"):
ip = e.properties.get(key)
if ip and len(ip) >= 2:
return (float(ip[0]), float(ip[1]))
bb = e.properties.get("bounding_box")
try:
if isinstance(bb, dict):
mn, mx = bb.get("min"), bb.get("max")
return ((mn[0] + mx[0]) / 2.0, (mn[1] + mx[1]) / 2.0)
if bb and len(bb) == 2 and hasattr(bb[0], "__len__"):
return ((bb[0][0] + bb[1][0]) / 2.0, (bb[0][1] + bb[1][1]) / 2.0)
if bb and len(bb) >= 4:
return ((bb[0] + bb[2]) / 2.0, (bb[1] + bb[3]) / 2.0)
except (TypeError, IndexError, KeyError):
return None
return None
async def _check_dim_overlap(backend: AutoCADBackend) -> list[Issue]:
"""Two dimensions whose reference points are within `tol` likely overlap.
Filters by entity TYPE (not layer) so dims land-anywhere — including the
iso13567 M-DIMEN-T-N layer — are still considered.
"""
tol = 5.0 # mm
try:
ents = await backend.entity_list(limit=5000)
except DocumentQuarantineError:
raise
except Exception:
return []
dim_points: list[tuple[str, tuple[float, float]]] = []
for e in ents:
if e.type not in _DIM_TYPES and "DIM" not in e.type:
continue
ip = _dim_ref_point(e)
if ip is not None:
dim_points.append((e.handle, ip))
issues: list[Issue] = []
seen: set[frozenset[str]] = set()
for i, (h1, p1) in enumerate(dim_points):
for j in range(i + 1, len(dim_points)):
h2, p2 = dim_points[j]
d = math.hypot(p1[0] - p2[0], p1[1] - p2[1])
if d <= tol:
key = frozenset((h1, h2))
if key in seen:
continue
seen.add(key)
issues.append(
Issue(
severity="warning",
focus="dim_overlap",
message=f"Dimensions {h1} and {h2} are {d:.2f} mm apart — likely overlapping.",
handles=[h1, h2],
)
)
return issues
async def _check_gdt(backend: AutoCADBackend) -> list[Issue]:
"""Every datum referenced by a feature control frame must have a matching
datum feature symbol.
ISO 1101 / ASME Y14.5: a position/orientation/runout FCF that cites datum A
is meaningless unless datum A is actually established on the part. The base
backend records referenced/defined datum letters as `draw_feature_control_frame`
and `draw_datum_feature` run, so this check needs no geometry parsing and is
identical on both engines.
"""
referenced = set(getattr(backend, "_gdt_datums_referenced", None) or set())
defined = set(getattr(backend, "_gdt_datums_defined", None) or set())
missing = sorted(referenced - defined)
if not missing:
return []
return [
Issue(
severity="error",
focus="gdt",
message=(
f"Feature control frame(s) reference datum(s) {missing} with no "
"matching datum feature. Add draw_datum_feature for each datum."
),
detail={
"missing_datums": missing,
"defined": sorted(defined),
"referenced": sorted(referenced),
},
)
]
_FOCUS_DISPATCH = {
"iso128": _check_iso128,
"layer_color": _check_layer_color,
"dim_overlap": _check_dim_overlap,
"untrimmed_corner": _check_untrimmed_corner,
"duplicate_entities": _check_duplicate_entities,
"construction_left": _check_construction_left,
"gdt": _check_gdt,
}
async def run_critique(
backend: AutoCADBackend,
focus: list[CritiqueFocus] | None = None,
) -> list[Issue]:
"""Dispatch each requested focus check and return aggregated issues."""
foci = list(focus) if focus is not None else list(ALL_CRITIQUE_FOCUSES)
issues: list[Issue] = []
for f in foci:
check = _FOCUS_DISPATCH.get(f)
if check is None:
issues.append(
Issue(
severity="warning",
focus=f, # type: ignore[arg-type]
message=f"Unknown critique focus '{f}' (closed enum).",
)
)
continue
issues.extend(await check(backend))
return issues